Cover of Rebuttal by Betsy Curtis

Rebuttal by Betsy Curtis

Immortality may be only a matter of definition, or of point of view, as this answer to Arthur C. Clarke's famous 'The Star' proposes, through the story of Father Phillip Burt.

First published 1956 1950s English Hard SFSocial SF

Betsy Curtis's 1956 story is a thoughtful hard-SF and social-SF reply to one of the most celebrated SF stories ever written. Sharp, provocative golden-age SF. Read it for an eloquent counter-argument to Clarke's 'The Star,' offering a wholly new idea about faith, sacrifice, and the divine.

In its time
Published in 1956, during the 1950s, post-war optimism meets cold war anxiety.
Reading it
14 min read (a short story, a single idea, delivered and gone).
Illustrated by
John Giunta

Ratings & reviews

0 ratings
5★ 0
4★ 0
3★ 0
2★ 0
1★ 0

What readers say

No written reviews yet.

Reader comments 0

No comments yet. Sign in to be the first.

More by Betsy Curtis

Temptress of Planet Delight
Cover of Temptress of Planet Delight by Betsy Curtis
Temptress of Planet Delight
Betsy Curtis · 1953
1 hr 17 min read
First ContactSpace Opera
The Old Ones
Cover of The Old Ones by Betsy Curtis
The Old Ones
Betsy Curtis · 1950
1 hr 14 min read
ColonizationSocial SF
The Protector
Cover of The Protector by Betsy Curtis
The Protector
Betsy Curtis · 1951
13 min read
DystopiaSocial SF
The Trap
Cover of The Trap by Betsy Curtis
The Trap
Betsy Curtis · 1953
21 min read
First ContactSocial SF

Readers also enjoyed

Revenge
Cover of Revenge by Arthur Porges
Revenge
Arthur Porges · 1959
11 min read
Hard SFSocial SF
The Gently Orbiting Blonde
Cover of The Gently Orbiting Blonde by John Victor Peterson
The Gently Orbiting Blonde
John Victor Peterson · 1957
17 min read
Hard SFSocial SF
Sam, This Is You
Cover of Sam, This Is You by Murray Leinster
Sam, This Is You
Murray Leinster · 1955
30 min read
Hard SFSocial SF
The Holes Around Mars
Cover of The Holes Around Mars by Jerome Bixby
The Holes Around Mars
Jerome Bixby · 1954
31 min read
Hard SFSocial SF
The Man Who Was Six
Cover of The Man Who Was Six by F. L. Wallace
The Man Who Was Six
F. L. Wallace · 1954
1 hr 1 min read
Hard SFSocial SF
The Laboratorians
Cover of The Laboratorians by Edward Peattie
The Laboratorians
Edward Peattie · 1955
21 min read
Hard SFSocial SF